A recent protest against P&O Cruises’ Ventura ship has ignited a fierce debate about the environmental impact of the cruise industry. Activists from Extinction Rebellion targeted the vessel in Rotterdam, branding it a “floating environmental disaster.” This article delves into the heart of the controversy, exploring the protest, the environmental concerns, and the future of cruising.
The Rotterdam Protest: A Stand Against “Floating Environmental Disasters”
On August 24, 2025, the P&O cruise ship Ventura was met with an unexpected welcome in Rotterdam. Activists from the environmental group Extinction Rebellion staged a protest, attempting to block the vessel from docking. Around fifteen protesters in small boats and canoes navigated the Maas River, aiming to obstruct the 116,000-tonne ship’s path to its berth. The protest caused a delay of approximately 30 minutes before local police intervened, dispersing the demonstrators and making two arrests.
Extinction Rebellion claimed responsibility for the action on social media, declaring that they would continue such protests unless the Dutch government bans the cruise industry. The group labelled cruise ships “floating environmental disasters,” highlighting their significant contribution to air and water pollution. The protest wasn’t confined to the water; a demonstration also took place on land, with activists displaying banners and chanting as the Ventura eventually moored. This incident is not an isolated one. Extinction Rebellion has targeted other cruise ships in the Netherlands, including vessels from Celebrity Cruises, Royal Caribbean, Ambassador Cruise Line, and Regent Seven Seas.
The Environmental Impact of Cruising: A Closer Look
The protest against the Ventura has brought the environmental credentials of the cruise industry under intense scrutiny. Campaigners from groups like Extinction Rebellion and Friends of the Earth have long argued that cruise ships are a significant source of pollution. One of the main concerns is air pollution. Cruise ships traditionally burn heavy fuel oil, a waste product from the oil industry, which is high in sulphur and other pollutants. According to a report by Transport & Environment, a European clean transport campaign group, a single large cruise ship can emit as much sulphur as one billion cars. These emissions have been linked to over 400,000 premature deaths a year globally.
Water pollution is another major issue. Cruise ships generate vast amounts of sewage and greywater from showers, sinks, and laundries. While some ships have advanced sewage treatment systems, many still discharge undertreated or even raw sewage into the sea. Friends of the Earth’s 2022 cruise ship report card gave P&O Cruises a ‘D’ for sewage treatment and an ‘F’ for air pollution reduction and water quality. The use of exhaust gas scrubbers, designed to reduce air pollution, is also controversial as they can convert air pollution into water pollution by discharging contaminated water into the sea.
P&O Cruises, like other major cruise lines, is facing increasing pressure to clean up its act. The company has stated its commitment to sustainability, investing in new low-carbon technologies and installing advanced air quality systems. Two of its newest ships, Iona and Arvia, are powered by liquefied natural gas (LNG), which is a cleaner burning fuel than heavy fuel oil. However, critics point out that LNG, while reducing some pollutants, can release significant amounts of methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
A History of Controversy: The P&O Ferries Scandal
While the recent protest against the Ventura was focused on environmental issues, the P&O brand has also been in the headlines for another controversy. In March 2022, P&O Ferries, a separate entity from P&O Cruises but owned by the same parent company, DP World, sparked outrage by sacking 800 of its UK-based crew members via a video message and replacing them with cheaper agency staff. The move was widely condemned by unions and the UK government, leading to protests at ports across the country. The scandal severely damaged the P&O brand’s reputation in the UK and has led to ongoing legal challenges.
The Future of Cruising: A Turning Tide?
The protests against the Ventura and other cruise ships, coupled with growing public awareness of environmental issues, suggest that the cruise industry is at a crossroads. While the allure of a luxury holiday at sea remains strong for many, the industry’s environmental and social impact is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore. The recent actions by groups like Extinction Rebellion are a clear signal that the pressure for change is mounting. Whether the industry can navigate these choppy waters and chart a course towards a more sustainable future remains to be seen.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What was the P&O Ventura cruise ship protest about?
The protest, organized by Extinction Rebellion in Rotterdam on August 24, 2025, was against the environmental impact of the cruise industry. Protesters in kayaks and canoes attempted to block the Ventura from docking, calling cruise ships “floating environmental disasters”.
2. What are the main environmental concerns with cruise ships?
The primary concerns are air and water pollution. Cruise ships emit large quantities of sulphur and other pollutants from burning heavy fuel oil, and can discharge undertreated sewage and other wastewater into the sea.
3. What is P&O Cruises doing to address these concerns?
P&O Cruises says it is investing in new technologies to reduce its environmental impact, including building new ships powered by liquefied natural gas (LNG) and installing advanced air quality systems on its existing fleet. However, the use of LNG has also drawn criticism due to methane emissions.
4. Are protests against cruise ships common?
Yes, protests against cruise ships by environmental groups like Extinction Rebellion have become more frequent in recent years, particularly in European ports.
5. What was the P&O Ferries scandal?
In March 2022, P&O Ferries, a separate company to P&O Cruises, sacked 800 UK-based crew members without notice and replaced them with lower-paid agency workers, leading to widespread protests and condemnation.
Leave a Reply